Download Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox
Again, reviewing habit will certainly always give helpful advantages for you. You might not have to invest numerous times to check out the book Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox Simply reserved several times in our spare or spare times while having meal or in your workplace to review. This Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox will show you brand-new point that you could do now. It will certainly aid you to enhance the top quality of your life. Event it is simply an enjoyable book Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox, you can be happier and a lot more enjoyable to delight in reading.
Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox
Download Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox
Discover the key to enhance the lifestyle by reading this Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox This is a type of book that you require now. Besides, it can be your favored book to review after having this publication Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox Do you ask why? Well, Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox is a publication that has various unique with others. You may not should understand who the author is, how well-known the work is. As sensible word, never ever evaluate the words from who talks, however make the words as your inexpensive to your life.
For everybody, if you intend to start joining with others to review a book, this Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox is much suggested. And also you should get the book Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox here, in the link download that we supply. Why should be below? If you really want various other kind of publications, you will certainly always locate them as well as Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox Economics, politics, social, scientific researches, faiths, Fictions, and much more publications are supplied. These offered publications are in the soft documents.
Why should soft data? As this Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox, many people also will need to purchase guide faster. Yet, occasionally it's up until now means to get the book Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox, also in various other nation or city. So, to alleviate you in locating the books Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox that will certainly support you, we aid you by offering the listings. It's not just the listing. We will certainly give the recommended book Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox web link that can be downloaded and install straight. So, it will not require even more times and even days to pose it and other books.
Gather guide Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox begin with currently. Yet the new means is by accumulating the soft documents of the book Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox Taking the soft documents can be conserved or stored in computer system or in your laptop. So, it can be greater than a book Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox that you have. The easiest method to expose is that you could additionally save the soft data of Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox in your ideal as well as available gadget. This condition will certainly suppose you frequently check out Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox in the spare times more than chatting or gossiping. It will not make you have bad habit, but it will certainly lead you to have better practice to check out book Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, By Alvin Coox.
From May to September 1939 Japan and the Soviet Union fought a fierce, large-scale undeclared war on the Mongolian plains that ended with a decisive Soviet victory with two important results: Japan reoriented its strategic emphasis towards the south, leading to war with the United States, Britain, and the Netherlands; and Russia freed itself from the fear of fighting on two fronts, thus vitally affecting the course of the war with Germany.
- Sales Rank: #829916 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Stanford University Press
- Published on: 1990-09-01
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.06" h x 2.21" w x 6.13" l, 3.61 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 1276 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
Review
"Monumental. . . . The culmination of 35 years of research. . . . The finest English-language study written by a single author on modern Asian military history. Indeed, it is arguably a military history classic of any age and any language."
—Mark R. Peattie
,The American Historical Review
"A masterpiece of narrative, documentation, and analysis."
—Alan K. Lathrop
,Military Affairs
"This splendid book gives not only the history of the conflict but sets it against the background of Japanese, Soviet, and world politics, while providing fascinating information on the internal workings of the Japanese army prior to the Pacific War."
—Denis Sinor
,Journal of Asian History
From the Back Cover
'This splendid book gives not only the history of the conflict but sets it against the background of Japanese, Soviet, and world politics, while providing fascinating information on the internal working of the Japanese army prior to the Pacific War.' -Denis Sinor, Journal of Asian History
Most helpful customer reviews
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful.
Why you should read this book.
By A Customer
Although this book is indeed long, it does not seem long because it is very well written. The subject is fascinating as well, deepening and clarifying one's understanding of the causes and conduct of WWII. The fact that this was a modern military campaign fought in the heartland of the former Mongol Empire adds to the interest. The Japanese were a long way from home at Nomonhan.
His description of the hardships of the Japanese troops is very poignant. A particularly important point foreshadowing the conduct and course of the Pacific War was the assumption by the officer corps that the bravery and endurance of Japanese troops would make up for grave deficiencies in their equipment and supply. The Japanese troops were of course profoundly brave, going to great lengths to rescue pieces of regimental flags, in a manner reminiscent of 18th century warfare, and attacking and defeating Russian tanks with cider bottles filled with gasoline. Coox notes that in the later phases of the campaign the Russians used diesel powered tanks, which negated the effectiveness of the "Molotov cocktail" attacks. This forshadowing of the attitudes and tactics of the Japanese Army alone makes the book well worth reading for any student of American military history.
Perhaps a more important point, one that really isn't made in Coox's book, and a piece of the puzzle only put together for me while recently reading Russia and the West under Lenin and Stalin by George Kennan, is that this campaign occurred at the same time as the Munich debacle in Europe, and was one of the factors motivating Stalin to reach an accomodation with Hitler in the notorious Non-Aggression Pact of 1939. Stalin was well aware of Soviet military weakness and was desperate to avoid simultaneous war with Germany and Japan.
Several reviewers commented on the lack of coverage of the Soviet side of the campaign. I don't consider this a deficiency, if it is understood at the outset that this is a description of the Japanese side. The Soviet side of the story has yet to be told, so far as I know. One can hope that whoever eventually tells it will tell it half as well as Coox has told the Japanese side.
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful.
wonderful, thorough long
By Seth J. Frantzman
The best and almost the only book on the conflist at Nomonhan. This was an epic battle that took place in 1939 between Japanese forces and Russians under the command of Zhukov. In this conlfict it quickly became obivous that the japanese forces were vastly inferior to their russian counterparts. Although brave the Japanese Armor, and planes and weapons were inferior. Zhukov, a military genious, eventually routed the japanese army causing horrendous losses to an army that had hiterhto only known victory against the militarily inferior Chinese.
Russia gained a hero from this conflcit, Zhukov. He was able to test his theories regarding the goruping of armor, and his victorious tactics would later be used against the Germans.
Nomonhan should have ended the superiority complex of the japanee military. They should have taken these lessons to heart. Unfortunatly the only thing they learned was that they should not try a full scale invasion of russia(this is why they did not help Hitler in 1941). They should have learned that America would have even better technology then the russians and a war with America would be disastrous.
Nomonhan is a fascinitating story of two imperial countries facing off for months of brutal fighting in which thousands perished and yet neither country declared war oin the other. This mirrors the confrontations between Russia and China in the 60s and the confrntatiosn between China and India in the 50/60s when it became apparent that the Indians were no match for the Chinese(thus shattering Nehrus nerves).
A very long book, very detailed with easy to read amps detailing the campaigns. The classic and sure to be the staple on this subject for decades to come. The other 'Nomonhan' book by Colvin is weak and inaccurate. This 'Nomonhan' is written mostly from the Japanese point of view, thats its only downside.
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful.
Lessons unlearned
By Harry Eagar
At the end of a thousand pages about the 'little war' at Nomonha/Khalkin Gol, Alvin Coox asks what lessons were learned.
For the Japanese, the answer is one word: Nothing.
In one sense, the 20th century was created by a series of wars entered into by people who could have had no rational expectation of winning: Austria in 1914, Germany in 1939, Japan in 1941, the Arabs in 1967. Of these (and I could adduce a few others, including some in which the underdogs did win) only the Japanese and the Arabs got the chance to run a preview, which ought to have inspired them to peacefulness but didn't.
One reason to spend so much time with 'Nomonhan' is that Coox nails down that the Japanese were inferior in every way -- and in ways that no sane person could mistake. Except one. The endurance and bravery of the Japanese soldiers was outstanding.
But they were poorly armed, poorly fed, poorly led. The battlefield at Nomonhan was scarcely 100 square miles in extent, but the division (later, Sixth Army) commanders seldom knew where their units were, and the colonels of the 4 infantry regiments were usually not in touch with each other.
It beggars belief that men, in Tokyo or Hsiking (the HQ of the Kwantung Army), thought they could engage in war over a quarter of the world's surface when they could not manage their army in an area the size of a township.
As Coox says, the Japanese went into Nomonhan assuming that their experience in China was relevant to warfare with anyone else. It is also true, though Coox does not say so, that in its brief existence, the Imperial Japanese Army never prevailed against a first-class opponent.
At Nomonhan, the Red Army was not first-class (although Richard Overy, in 'Russia's War,' gives it that status). The Red Army was, then, only an emerging second-class army, but it did have first-class doctrine: combined arms used in a massive fashion -- the strategy that won its war against Germany.
Even if the Japanese had had sane leadership, Japan simply didn't have the economic base to play in the big leagues. The nation's leaders were not, by any rational standard, sane. Nomonhan, and the Pacific War, were fought by men with medieval minds and modern weapons.
This is a phenomenon not restricted to the Japanese, and the best reason to read 'Nomonhan' is to understand, in the 21st century, how much damage that combination can do to the world. And what to do about it.
You cannot negotiate your way out of it, as the Russians discovered.
I do have a few problems with Coox's book. The maps are inadequate and poorly designed. The claims of battle damage are not credible. Only occasionally does Coox express (usually in the endnotes) any skepticism about the claims.
This is particularly troubling in the air force claims. We know, from after-action studies, that in, say, the Solomon Islands fighting, the aerial claims of each side were vastly inflated. Coox is in a pickle here, as he has no alternative to reporting what's in the unit reports, but he should have flagged their unreliability.
I also am doubtful about his conclusions that, in the end, the Japanese and Russians suffered roughly equal casualties. The Russians, in general, and Zhukov in particular, did not worry excessively about own casualties, but the description of the fighting shows the Russians either relying on defense in depth or, on offense, making probing attacks without pressing them home against intact Japanese units. Neither tactic generates the kind of casualties that the Japanese tactics of headlong frontal assault do.
Even assuming that the Russians were not very expert (a good assumption for that year of 1939 and several more years), I doubt the Russians came anywhere near Japanese casualty levels.
Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox PDF
Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox EPub
Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox Doc
Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox iBooks
Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox rtf
Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox Mobipocket
Nomonhan: Japan Against Russia, 1939, by Alvin Coox Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar